Jan 19, 2022

When you get that special craving, nothing else will satisfy you. We’d love to point you in the direction of the best pizza in San Angelo, TX. Naturally, we have all the regular chains, but there’s some much better pizza out there.

Where to Find the Best Pizza Near San Angelo, TX

Trophy’s

Tropy’s is over at 4325 Southwest Blvd, and they’re open for takeout and delivery. This is a quick-serve place that you’ll love. They open at noon during weekdays and close at 8 pm. On Friday and Saturday, they open at 11 am and don’t close until 9 pm. On Sundays, they’re only open for dinner from 4 pm until 8 pm.

This is a beloved local spot with melt-in-your-mouth calzones, perfectly cooked pizzas, and a fast, friendly staff you’ll enjoy dealing with. They offer hand-tossed, deep dish, and thin-crust pizzas, calzones, wings, pasta, and salads. We highly recommend the cinnamon sticks for a bit of dessert, too.

Lily’s

Lily’s is at 2424 Vanderventer Ave and is open for lunch from 11 am to 2 pm and for dinner from 5 pm until 9 pm, Tue through Sat. On Sundays, they stay open from noon until 9 pm. Their food is good, the prices are awesome, and the service is friendly. You can also watch your game here and bring your own beer: if you do, please drink responsibly and never drink and drive.

The white pizza is a particular favorite here, and the sauce and homemade dough are what really make this pizza. You don’t want to miss their nanjos, though, and the baked subs are a lunch staple in San Angelo. We’re also fond of the baked parm.

DoubleDave’s Pizzaworks

At 3536 Knickerbocker Rd, DoubleDave’s is open from 11 am until 9 pm. Tues through Sun. On Friday and Saturday, they stay open an extra hour. We love the staff here in particular: they’re friendly, kind, fast, and a joy to be around. They deliver, even to nearby hotels, and they have daily specials it’s worth checking out.

We love the soft, pillowy crust, the generous toppings (but not so much grease that it’s all you taste), and the handcrafted Peroni Rolls. The Dave’s Fave pizza is not to be missed, and you won’t have a better Meateater anywhere. Build your own if you prefer, and the Caulipower gluten-free crust is great for those with allergies or just anyone who wants to minimize their carbs.

Old Central Firehouse

At 200a S Magdalen St, Old Central Firehouse is closed on Sun-Mon and open from 11 am to 8 pm during the week and until 9 pm on Frid and Sat. The pizza here is absolutely amazing: it might just be that we’ve saved the best for last in our reviews (though there’s always arguments about something as important as pizza).

The Alarm and BBQ pizzas are perfect if you love some heat to your pie. Mushroom Madness, the brisket pizza, and the Firestarter are other local favorites you’ll want to try if you’re looking for something different. But the pepperoni, margherita, and sausage pizzas are all great if you want something more run-of-the-mill.

If you need more suggestions for the best slices in town, or to get the service you need to keep your vehicle running right, stop by and see us at Randall Cadillac!